Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ed Bradford's avatar

As always, I find your essay's fascinating. I'll respond

to this essay first then ask a question for a possible

future H.W. Brands essay.

As BossyPantSU points out, John Adams mentions

"moral and religious people" as a necessary foundation to

sustain the American experiment. A number of studies of the era

conclude that our founders all were Deists or

Christians (it is suggested that one might have

been atheist). Most of them testified that America

without morality will fail (as in the John Adams

quote and George Washington's Farewell

Address). It has been recognized by many

(majority?) of historians that religion informed

(begat) morality for all in 1776 America.

[See the Washington's Farewell Address paragraph

starting with:

"Of all the dispositions and habits, ..." paragraph.

Here is the entire paragraph:]

Of all the dispositions and habits, which

lead to political prosperity, Religion and

Morality are indispensable supports. In

vain would that man claim the tribute of

Patriotism, who should labor to subvert

these great pillars of human happiness,

these firmest props of the duties of

Men and Citizens. The mere Politician,

equally with the pious man, ought to

respect and to cherish them. A volume

could not trace all their connexions with

private and public felicity. Let it simply

be asked, Where is the security for

property, for reputation, for life, if the

sense of religious obligation desert the

oaths, which are the instruments of

investigation in Courts of Justice? And

let us with caution indulge the

supposition, that morality can be

maintained without religion. Whatever

may be conceded to the influence of

refined education on minds of peculiar

structure, reason and experience both

forbid us to expect, that national

morality can prevail in exclusion of

religious principle.

George Washington was prescient.

America moving away from God, presents an

unknown future and probably (in my opinion) is the

foundation of the discord in America today.

Here is my question for a future H. W. Brands essay.

Our founders mentioned morality frequently. Most declared that without

morality, the American experiment would fail. None ever defined "morality".

Did they all have a collective and mostly synchronous understanding of "morality"?

Were not all of their "moralities" derived from Christianity? Did any of them

comprehend in any detail other religions at the time of 1787 when

the American constitution was written?

Expand full comment
Howard Ahmanson's avatar

This essay is commendable for separating the First Table, to use Calvinist terminology (religion) from the Second (morality) . The first is no business of the state. The second is the basis of our laws. Remove everything moral from the law and all you have left is crony capitalism.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts