Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard Munro's avatar

neutrality for Ukraine is a possibility in the long run. I would have no problem with that. But I think the war will go on until 1) Putin is overthrown or defeated or 2) Putin dies. I don't think most Russians really want to war to go on.

The bottom line is Ukraine voted overwhelmingly for independence and wants to be part of a free Europe. If Russia can cancel the independence and votes of a nation then who in Europe is safe?

Expand full comment
DENNIS B MURPHY's avatar

A couple thoughts on this excellent piece.

First, I think focusing on Hitler as a 'cause' of WW2 is to avoid what Mr Brands's points to in the article. He references empires and overseas possessions. As Richard Overy illustrates in his book "Blood and Ruins: The Last Imperial War, 1931-1945" the Axis powers wanted empires also. Obviously, we cannot go back in time to demonstrate alternative history, but in my opinion, given how the Axis were treated after WW1 a WW2 was inevitable.

There may be some loose parallels with the current Ukrainian war instigated by Russia. Putin's ideological godfather, Alexander Dugin, has been at the forefront for years inciting the Russian nation to build back its empire and while doing so, demonizing and dehumanizing nearby nations such as Ukraine calling them sub-human and 'not a real nation."

But this is the 21st century! Wars of conquest and territory should not occur. I agree with Richard Munro's comment below. Finland and Sweden were neutral, but Putin's aggression pushed them into pursuing alliance. The Baltic's knew immediately all too well how Russia operates and allied as soon as they could after independence.

And Jack Henneman puts bluntly a point seemingly ignored by Putin apologists in the west (oddly, from both the far left AND far right) that Russia had already given Ukraine security guarantees in connection with the international deal to induce Ukraine to give up its nuclear weapons yet breached those agreements continuously since 2014.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts